Closed Sessions
118 Illinois PAC opinions and determination letters about closed sessions.
Practical next steps: Guide to closed-session records
Closed Sessions: what the decisions show
This topic covers when a public body may close part of a meeting to the public. The decisions address the scope of exceptions for personnel matters, real property, and litigation, as well as procedures for entering closed session, documenting the basis, making verbatim recordings, and the requirement to take final action in open session.
Across these decisions, the Public Access Counselor found violations where discussion went beyond the cited exception, such as general budget, salary, or property matters discussed as specific employees or real estate, where litigation was cited without a qualifying basis, where final action was taken in closed session, and where majorities of members met privately without proper notice and procedure. The holdings emphasize keeping closed discussion narrowly within the authorized topic and conducting other business openly.
At a glance: 118 documents from 1972 to 2026(28 binding opinions, 90 determination letters). Outcome: 76 found a violation (in whole or part), 23 found none. Most often cited alongside: 5 ILCS 120/2(c)(1) (Employee/contractor appointment, discipline, or performance) (18); 5 ILCS 120/2(c)(11) (Pending, probable, or imminent litigation) (17); 5 ILCS 120/2(c) (General closed-session exceptions) (16); 5 ILCS 120/2(c)(5) (Purchase or lease of real property) (5); 5 ILCS 120/2(c)(6) (Setting a sale/lease price for public body's own property) (5).
Recurring issues
- Public bodies cited real estate exceptions but discussed other property or financial matters outside that exception. (Closed-session discussion of real property acquisition, Closed-session discussion of property sale or lease pricing, A board's closed-session discussion of property sale or lease)
- Public bodies cited the exception for specific employees but discussed general topics such as budgets, layoffs, across-the-board raises, elected officials, or evaluation processes. (Closed-session discussion of budget and layoff decisions, Closed-session discussion of employee pay raises, A finance committee's closed-session discussion of elected officials' duties and salaries)
- Public bodies took final action during closed session instead of voting in open session. (City council's closed-session authorization of a real estate contract, A board's final vote on closed session minutes)
- Public bodies entered closed session without proper procedure or held private gatherings of a majority of members without proper notice. (A village board's closed-session discussion of overdue loans, A county board's private informational meeting, A library board's unannounced private meeting)
Practical points
- Identify the specific closed-session exception and limit discussion to the matter within that exception.
- Take votes authorizing contracts or approving actions in open session rather than in closed session.
- Make and retain a verbatim recording of every closed session.
Summary drafted from the linked decisions and checked against them; read the decisions themselves before relying on it. Not legal advice.
- Closed-session discussion of real property acquisitionBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- A village board's closed-session discussion of overdue loansBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of an advisory opinionDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A school board's letter signed by a majority of membersDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A county board's private informational meetingBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session recordings for a trustee's reviewDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Board deliberation on a censure resolution outside a public meetingDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Closed-session discussion of pay raises and construction bidsDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a board vacancy and disciplineDetermination letter · Partial violation
Violation found, but no further remedial action necessary
- City council's closed-session authorization of a real estate contractBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a volunteer's performance and FOIA strategyDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of financial statements, transit cards, and newslettersDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussions of school closures and budget cutsDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- A board's transit discussion of public businessDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Destruction of closed-session audio recordingsDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a board member removalDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A village council's review of closed-session minutesDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A library board's unannounced private meetingBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of property sale or lease pricingBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- A board's final vote on closed session minutesBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a book's removal from curriculumBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Private board meetings to discuss appointing a village presidentDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A school board's closed-session discussion of a book removal policyDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A town council's closed-session discussion of litigation strategyDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Phone polls to vote on township businessDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of litigation and a resolutionDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- A board of ethics' closed-session discussion of a query reportDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of audit status and rule changesDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a property tax appealDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- A school board's closed-session personnel transfer of a principalDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussions of a 2016 sewer projectDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed due to untimeliness and pending litigation
- An unsworn official's attendance at a closed sessionDetermination letter · Closed no further action
No violation found
- Closed-session discussions of student disciplinary casesDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a pathway vacation ordinanceDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed due to untimeliness
- Closed-session discussion of transportation contract bidsBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a new school openingBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of water rates and tax leviesDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a mayor's salaryDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A city council's closed-session discussion of the city clerk positionDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Commissioners' discussions on property tax code amendmentsDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A city council's closed-session discussion of a conditional use permitDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A board's closed-session discussion of policy recommendationsDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a property saleDetermination letter · Violation found
No violation found
- Closed-session minutes and remote meeting noticeDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A county board's review of closed session minutes and recordingsDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Closed-session discussion of personnel mattersDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- A former board member's blog post with closed-session audioDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A school board's closed-session discussions and failure to review minutesDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A village board's exclusion of a trustee from closed sessionDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Closed-session discussion of sewer main issuesBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Failure to record a closed-session meetingBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed session discussion of an intergovernmental agreementDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A school board's emergency meeting notice and closed-session discussionsDetermination letter · Partial violation
Closed, no further action
- A board's private discussion of equipment purchasesDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Destruction of closed-session recordings by a university boardDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a principal evaluation processBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussions of a potential real estate purchaseDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Closed-session discussion of ethics complaint jurisdictionDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- A school board's closed-session discussion of a property sale priceDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Access to closed session verbatim recordingsDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Board members' emails coordinating a public statementDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Closed-session discussion of an executive director succession planDetermination letter · Partial violation
Partial violation found
- A committee's closed-session meeting at an undisclosed location without a recordingDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Email votes on public businessDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion about a library branch relocationDetermination letter · Partial violation
Partial violation found
- Approval of closed session minutes in a closed sessionDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A village board's closed-session discussion of personnel mattersDetermination letter · Partial violation
Partial violation found
- Closed-session discussion of board member conduct and policy changesDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Private meetings of city council members at local establishmentsDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A board's failure to cite a closed-session exceptionDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session vote citing pending litigationDetermination letter · Closed no further action
No violation found
- Closed-session discussion of budget and layoff decisionsBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- A finance committee's closed-session discussion of elected officials' duties and salariesBinding opinion · Violation found
- A school board's closed-session discussion of staffing strategyDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Private discussion of employee insurance coverageDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of potential litigationDetermination letter · Partial violation
Partial violation found
- A board retreat at a remote locationDetermination letter · Insufficient info
Insufficient information to conclude a violation
- Maintenance and storage of open session minutes and closed session recordingsDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session minutes for a school building bidDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A board member ordering a technician to stop recording a closed sessionDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A township board's destruction of a closed-session recordingDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a bidding processDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session self-evaluation of board proceduresDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Closed-session discussion of police service consolidationDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of committee appointmentsDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of non-litigation mattersDetermination letter · Partial violation
Partial violation found; disclosure ordered
- A committee's failure to review closed session minutesDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A school council's failure to post a meeting agenda and closed-session discussion of candidate selectionDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- A university board's selection of a presidentDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- A city council's closed-session discussion of a revenue-sharing agreementBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a board member's conductBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- A separation agreement approved by a city councilDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Closed-session discussion of kindergarten programmingDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a cell tower lease proposalDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- Joint sessions of a university board with affiliated foundation membersDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- School board meetings without a physical quorumDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- A village committee's gathering at a private residenceDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Closed-session termination of an employeeDetermination letter · Partial violation
Improper final action in closed session
- A city council's campaign fundraiser gatheringDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Closed-session discussion of possible litigationBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of employee pay raisesBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Board members' emails on a board seat and contractDetermination letter · Insufficient info
Insufficient information to conclude a violation
- A board's closed-session discussion of property sale or leaseBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of a police services contractBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- A finance committee's closed meeting on a hiring freezeBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- School board members' emails about appointmentsDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- Closed-session self-evaluation of board proceduresDetermination letter · No violation
No violation found
- A university board's closed-session vote to terminate a tenured faculty memberBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Closed-session discussion of litigation without recording basisBinding opinion · Partial violation
Partial violation found
- A school board's final action on a separation agreement in closed sessionBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- A school board's closed-session appointment of an interim superintendentBinding opinion · No violation
No violation found
- Closed-session discussion of municipal budgetary mattersBinding opinion · Violation found
Violation found
- Unrecorded closed-session landfill ordinance discussionBinding opinion · Violation found
- A committee's private discussion of a redistricting mapDetermination letter · Violation found
Violation found
- School board closed session on bargaining rightsDetermination letter · Other
- Merit Board advisory committee under the Open Meetings ActDetermination letter · Other
- Closed-session minutes and recordings of an investigationDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed, no further action
- School board closed session minutes over eight yearsDetermination letter · Closed no further action
Closed, no further action